News
News

Will AI assistants recommend your store? Bain says size isn't enough anymore

Short answer

Not on its own. A Bain & Company report published on 20 November 2026 found that market share no longer guarantees a retailer a place in AI shopping answers, and that category specialists often show up more than their size would suggest. AI assistants reward the stores that say most clearly who they serve and what they do best, so a smaller store with a clear, specific offer can win answers that a bigger one misses.

News cover: glowing blue dots forming a wave on a dark background, under the headline asking whether AI assistants will recommend your store.
On this page

    Key facts

    • Bain analysed more than 4,400 shopping prompts across four retail verticals, with over 300,000 unique runs across the most used AI models.
    • In many retail verticals, category specialists appear in AI answers more often than their market share would suggest.
    • Nearly 33% of US consumers and 36% of European consumers say they use AI assistants for some part of the shopping journey, up from 19% and 8% in 2025.
    • AI assistant referral traffic is still under 1% of retailers' web traffic, but Bain says it converts 90% better than non-AI traffic.
    • 55% of shoppers who use AI don't fully trust it to complete a purchase. Shoppers trust retailers' own assistants (21%) nearly twice as much as third-party ones (12%).

    What happened

    On 20 November 2026 Bain & Company published a report called AI Is the New Search. Here's How Retailers Win the Answer. Its headline finding: market share alone no longer gets a retailer into AI search answers. Bain's retail head, Aaron Cheris, put it this way: "AI assistants are rewarding the retailers that are clearest about who they serve and what they do best, because shoppers ask specific questions and specific answers win." He added that "AI visibility shifts constantly, so it needs the same ongoing attention as pricing or delivery."

    What this means for your store

    1. Say who you're for, in plain words. Your home page, main categories and best-selling products should state what you sell, who it's for and why you're the better pick. Bain calls this spelling out "your value proposition clearly for the bots".
    2. Build pages around occasions. Bain advises updating your most important pages for the occasions and promotions you want shoppers to see, in your customers' own words, before the final holiday rush. Our Black Friday guide covers getting sale prices right.
    3. Test what AI assistants say about you. Bain's first checklist item is a "prompt audit": ask assistants about the products and occasions that matter to your customers and see whether you appear. Specialists can have an edge here, as our post on Shopify's long-tail data also found.
    4. Don't judge AI by clicks alone. Many shoppers research with AI and then visit your site on their own, so referral numbers undercount its influence.

    The technical details

    Bain doesn't spell out the mechanics, but an assistant can only describe you well if it can read you. In our experience that means: AI search crawlers such as OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot are allowed in robots.txt and not blocked by your firewall; your positioning is in the page text, not only in images; Organization and Product structured data match what the page says; and prices and stock are accurate. Bain also tells large retailers to plan their own shopping assistant and decide how open it will be to outside agents. For most smaller stores, being clear to third-party assistants comes first.

    Want to know if AI assistants and agents can find, read and recommend your store? Check it with Web2Agents.

    FAQ

    Sources

    Newsletter

    New guides on AI visibility, in your inbox.

    Practical, sourced articles on AI crawlers, llms.txt, structured data and AI search. A new one every day.

    Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.